Introduction:
Toby Keith’s “What Made The Baby Cry?” is a contemplative ballad featured on his 1995 holiday album, Christmas to Christmas. Departing from his typical patriotic and often lighthearted country themes, Keith explores deeper spiritual and existential questions in this song. The track reflects on the birth of Jesus Christ, questioning whether the infant could sense the pain, suffering, and challenges of the world He was born into, as well as the sacrifices He would ultimately make.
Set against a serene yet introspective melody, the song contrasts the joy of new life with the solemnity of the world’s struggles. Keith’s lyrics highlight the contrast between the innocence of the Christ child and the harsh realities of humanity. He also ponders whether society has learned from the lessons of the past or if the pain that “made the baby cry” persists two millennia later.
“What Made The Baby Cry?” stands out among holiday songs for its reflective tone and profound messaging. Its focus on human struggles and the message of love and redemption offers listeners a thoughtful perspective during the festive season. As part of Christmas to Christmas, a collection of original holiday tracks, this song showcases Keith’s ability to delve into meaningful storytelling, making it a poignant addition to his discography.
Video: