Neil Diamond: The top 10 songs from rock's King of Guilty Pleasures | The Independent | The Independent

Introduction:

Few songs in popular music history have managed to capture the spirit of collective celebration quite like Neil Diamond – Sweet Caroline (Good Times Never Seemed So Good). Released in 1969, this enduring anthem has grown beyond the status of a chart-topping hit to become an intergenerational favorite—an emotional touchstone played at weddings, baseball games, parties, and moments of national triumph. Whether you hear it blaring from stadium speakers or sung in unison by crowds of thousands, the song’s uplifting chorus and catchy melody continue to bring people together more than half a century after its debut.

Neil Diamond, already an established songwriter by the late 1960s, crafted “Sweet Caroline” during a particularly creative stretch of his career. The song was reportedly written in just one hour and, despite its quick composition, turned out to be one of his most iconic works. It originally peaked at number four on the Billboard Hot 100 and eventually achieved multi-platinum status—yet its real legacy wasn’t fully cemented until years later, when it began to take on a life of its own in public consciousness.

At its core, “Sweet Caroline” is built on a simple, ascending melody that draws the listener in from the opening lines. The lyrics—“Where it began, I can’t begin to knowin’”—evoke a feeling of warmth and nostalgic curiosity, pulling the audience into a personal yet universally felt journey. The pre-chorus builds anticipation masterfully until it breaks into the famously jubilant refrain: “Sweet Caroline / Good times never seemed so good.” This line, in particular, has become a cultural shorthand for moments of optimism, resilience, and unity.

Part of the song’s charm lies in its accessibility. There’s nothing complicated about the instrumentation or structure, yet it’s precisely that simplicity that allows it to shine. The brass section bursts with confidence, and Diamond’s rich baritone delivers the lyrics with sincerity and soul. It’s a song that’s easy to sing along to—something that has led to its spontaneous adoption at sports arenas and public gatherings, where the audience joyfully fills in the “so good, so good, so good!” refrain.

Though originally recorded as a pop single, “Sweet Caroline” has aged into something much greater—a communal experience, an unofficial anthem of togetherness. In Boston, it became a tradition at Red Sox games following the September 11 attacks, and its performance at public events has often been used to inspire hope during trying times. What began as a romantic pop tune has transcended genre and generation, solidifying its place as one of the most beloved songs in the American musical canon.

In looking back on the success and staying power of Neil Diamond – Sweet Caroline (Good Times Never Seemed So Good), one finds more than a catchy tune. It is a testament to the joy that music can spark, the way a chorus can linger in the heart long after the music stops. It is a reminder that some melodies, no matter how old, never fade—they simply find new voices to carry them forward.

Video: