Introduction:
While Elvis Presley‘s name is synonymous with rock and roll anthems and electrifying stage presence, his musical journey ventured beyond the high-octane energy of his early hits. “Tell Me Why” stands as a testament to this artistic versatility, showcasing Presley’s ability to deliver a powerful and soulful ballad. Released in late 1965, the song became a sleeper hit despite its delayed arrival.
Composed by Titus Turner in 1956, “Tell Me Why” was originally a rhythm and blues ballad recorded by Marie Knight. The song garnered moderate success, particularly in regions like New Orleans and Texas. However, it was Presley’s rendition that truly brought the song to wider attention. Presley recorded “Tell Me Why” in 1957, but it remained unreleased for several years. The song’s eventual release in 1965 was a strategic move by Presley’s record label, RCA Victor. At the time, Presley was primarily focusing on soundtracks for his movies. “Tell Me Why,” along with other previously unreleased tracks, was released to fill the gap between soundtrack recordings.
Despite its delayed release, “Tell Me Why” resonated with audiences. Presley’s soulful vocals imbued the song with a depth of emotion, perfectly complementing the poignant lyrics that grapple with themes of heartbreak and unanswered questions. Billboard magazine described Presley’s version as a “slow blues rocker” and anticipated chart success based on its prior popularity in the UK. Their prediction proved accurate, with “Tell Me Why” peaking at number 33 on the Billboard Hot 100 and achieving gold record status. The song also found success on the UK Singles Chart, reaching number 15.
Though not one of Presley’s most iconic recordings, “Tell Me Why” holds a special place in his vast discography. It serves as a reminder of his ability to excel in various musical styles, captivating audiences with his soulful delivery. “Tell Me Why” continues to resonate with fans who appreciate Presley’s versatility and his willingness to explore the emotional depths of a ballad.