Introduction:
Conway Twitty’s 1958 hit “It’s Only Make Believe” marked a significant milestone in his career, showcasing his versatility and setting the stage for his future success in country music. Born Harold Lloyd Jenkins in Mississippi, Twitty adopted the stage name Conway Twitty in 1957 and initially pursued a rock and roll style.
Co-written by Twitty and drummer Jack Nance during a tour in Ontario, Canada, “It’s Only Make Believe” was recorded on May 7, 1958, at Bradley Studios in Nashville. The session featured notable musicians such as Floyd Cramer on piano and Grady Martin on guitar, with the Jordanaires providing backing vocals.
Released by MGM Records on July 14, 1958, as the B-side to “I’ll Try,” the song initially garnered attention from a DJ in Columbus, Ohio, who favored “It’s Only Make Believe.” This led to its national popularity, culminating in a two-week stint at No. 1 on the Billboard chart in November 1958. The song also topped the UK Singles Chart, solidifying Twitty’s international appeal.
The success of “It’s Only Make Believe” was instrumental in Twitty’s transition from rock and roll to country music. Although he didn’t become a country star until 1966, the song’s popularity demonstrated his potential in the genre.
Over the years, the song has been covered by various artists, including Glen Campbell, who achieved a top 10 hit with his rendition in 1970. Twitty’s original version remains a testament to his enduring talent and adaptability in the ever-evolving music landscape.