Introduction:
Toby Keith’s song “What Made the Baby Cry?” is a contemplative piece from his 1995 album Christmas to Christmas, an album that diverges from the usual upbeat holiday fare to explore deeper themes. Unlike typical Christmas songs, “What Made the Baby Cry?” focuses on the nativity story and poses a unique question: could the baby Jesus sense the world’s suffering and challenges even at birth? This reflective song moves beyond simple celebration, instead pondering the complexities of life and the human condition, suggesting that even joyful events like birth are tinged with an awareness of life’s hardships.
The song is a heartfelt reminder of the emotional and spiritual weight of the Christmas story, and it reflects Keith’s knack for storytelling, although he is often more associated with patriotic anthems and rowdy hits. In “What Made the Baby Cry?”, Keith’s somber and soulful approach sheds light on the contrast between innocence and the foreboding future that lies ahead, creating a Christmas tune with a poignant twist. This track is notable for its introspective quality, inviting listeners to reflect on the meaning behind the holiday and the complexities of life itself.
For fans looking to explore a more thoughtful and spiritually resonant side of Christmas music, this song offers a unique and lasting impression. It’s a standout piece in Keith’s early discography, showing his versatility and willingness to engage with meaningful themes in his music.